top of page

Executive Summary

The SafeCU UX teardown exposes weaknesses in the homepage’s signup path, interaction logic, and accessibility. The hero section carries the highest drop‑off risk, rate tiles lack essential system‑status feedback, and multiple WCAG failures reduce clarity and trust. Addressing a small set of high‑impact issues significantly improves acquisition, mobile usability, and compliance.

Signup Path
Six-Step Path to Application 
Break one link, conversion collapses
Copilot_20260728_095332_edited.jpg

SafeCU Homepage Teardown

safe_credit_union_panel_image.png

Key Findings

SAFE Credit Union represents a high-traffic regional financial platform serving over 100k users daily. This teardown conducts a rigorous analysis based on NN/g principles, revealing key UI bottlenecks and architectural flaws that cause friction in the consumer signup process. Below, find actionable recommendations to elevate interaction quality.

  • The hero CTA is a single point of failure; if it breaks, acquisition collapses.

  • Trust signals are missing at the decision moment, causing early abandonment.

  • Rate tiles lack loading, freshness, and error states, weakening rate‑shopper confidence.

  • Loan applicants lose context due to an auth gate mid‑flow.

  • The homepage relies on a strict dependency chain: Brand → Hero → Features → Rates → CTA → Form.

  • Form validation fires only on submit, increasing error recovery friction.

  • Multiple WCAG 2.1 failures reduce accessibility and legal compliance.

  • Mobile CTAs and badges fail minimum tap‑target standards.

  • Blog and Features Grid share identical patterns, confusing content priority.

  • Footer columns lack hierarchy, slowing task recovery.

  • Onboarding is the highest drop‑off stage, with 40% abandoning early.

  • The moment users see the value by day 3 is the strongest retention multiplier (2.4×).

Actionable Recommendations

Untitled_edited.jpg

Click buttons below to compare SafeCU Home Page against interactive prototype. 

PowerPoint Artifacts

​​Journey Map
Five‑stage experience with onboarding as the highest drop‑off risk and advocacy as the strongest growth loop.

​

​

​

Interaction Logic Specification
60+ interactions documented as Trigger → Action → State → Feedback across all homepage sections.

​​WCAG 2.1 Audit
12 fails, 25 warnings; seven low‑effort fixes unlock Level A compliance.

Usability Issues
20 issues (3 critical, 6 high, 6 medium, 5 low) with concrete fixes mapped to Nielsen heuristics.

​

bottom of page